Yeah! This was the actually the first post I tried to write. But it petered out a few times, so I approached it from a different angle and came up with the post above instead. I definitely agree that “robustness” is something that should be seen as a pillar of EA—boringly overdetermined interventions just seem a lot more likely to survive repeated contact with reality to me, and I think as we’ve moved away from geeking out about RCTs we’ve lost some of that caution as a communtiy.
Yeah! This was the actually the first post I tried to write. But it petered out a few times, so I approached it from a different angle and came up with the post above instead. I definitely agree that “robustness” is something that should be seen as a pillar of EA—boringly overdetermined interventions just seem a lot more likely to survive repeated contact with reality to me, and I think as we’ve moved away from geeking out about RCTs we’ve lost some of that caution as a communtiy.