Not disagreeing with Michael_Wiebe, but just thought I’d add this: the SNT framework is just a few rules of thumb anyway. Where people can produce expected value calculations of the intervention in question (e.g. good done/pound), they should just do that. But SNT is a good place to start.
And if your disagreement is with the scale/tractability/neglectedness framework, then argue against that directly.
Not disagreeing with Michael_Wiebe, but just thought I’d add this: the SNT framework is just a few rules of thumb anyway. Where people can produce expected value calculations of the intervention in question (e.g. good done/pound), they should just do that. But SNT is a good place to start.