I agree substituting the question would be bad, and sometimes there aren’t any relevant experts in which case you shouldn’t defer to people. (Though even then I’d consider doing research in an unrelated area for a couple of years, and then coming back to work on the question of interest.)
I admit I don’t really understand how people manage to have a “driving question” overwritten—I can’t really imagine that happening to me and I am confused about how it happens to other people.
(I think sometimes it is justified, e.g. you realize that your question was confused, and the other work you’ve done has deconfused it, but it does seem like often it’s just that they pick up the surrounding culture and just forget about the question they cared about in the first place.)
So I guess this seems like a possible risk. I’d still bet pretty strongly against any particular junior researcher’s intuition being better, so I still think this advice is good on net.
(I’m mostly not engaging with the quantum example because it sounds like a very just-so story to me and I don’t know enough about the area to evaluate the just-so story.)
I agree substituting the question would be bad, and sometimes there aren’t any relevant experts in which case you shouldn’t defer to people. (Though even then I’d consider doing research in an unrelated area for a couple of years, and then coming back to work on the question of interest.)
I admit I don’t really understand how people manage to have a “driving question” overwritten—I can’t really imagine that happening to me and I am confused about how it happens to other people.
(I think sometimes it is justified, e.g. you realize that your question was confused, and the other work you’ve done has deconfused it, but it does seem like often it’s just that they pick up the surrounding culture and just forget about the question they cared about in the first place.)
So I guess this seems like a possible risk. I’d still bet pretty strongly against any particular junior researcher’s intuition being better, so I still think this advice is good on net.
(I’m mostly not engaging with the quantum example because it sounds like a very just-so story to me and I don’t know enough about the area to evaluate the just-so story.)