(20% Wild Animal Welfare) Nice poll, but tough call! With the little we know, the effects of interventions on wild animals seem likely to outweigh those on farmed animals. However, we do not have a clear notion of how current wild animal interventions (even field-building and research) will affect wild animals in the long run (though this is also true of interventions that don’t aim to help wild animals).
I do not think a “robust” and “safe” pick in animal welfare exists yet (that we’re aware of): under the current state of my uncertainties, I’m voting with my dollars on invertebrate welfare interventions (though those are still probably outweighed by effects on wild invertebrates). Though I’m gradually seeing the appeal of funding more research (especially on small wild animals).
Slightly in favor of wild animal welfare here, because it seems likely that if we gain enough knowledge to find a robust intervention in animal welfare, it will target wild animals directly or indirectly (since they’re probably the dominant group of moral patients).
(20% Wild Animal Welfare)
Nice poll, but tough call! With the little we know, the effects of interventions on wild animals seem likely to outweigh those on farmed animals. However, we do not have a clear notion of how current wild animal interventions (even field-building and research) will affect wild animals in the long run (though this is also true of interventions that don’t aim to help wild animals).
I do not think a “robust” and “safe” pick in animal welfare exists yet (that we’re aware of): under the current state of my uncertainties, I’m voting with my dollars on invertebrate welfare interventions (though those are still probably outweighed by effects on wild invertebrates). Though I’m gradually seeing the appeal of funding more research (especially on small wild animals).
Slightly in favor of wild animal welfare here, because it seems likely that if we gain enough knowledge to find a robust intervention in animal welfare, it will target wild animals directly or indirectly (since they’re probably the dominant group of moral patients).