It does seem like some of the “serious” GHD discussion is moving off the forum, e.g. later today I’m attending this online workshop (more info) that touches on your 3rd bullet. This seems part of the wider trend of decision-influencing discussion becoming internalised due to the professionalisation of EA GHD, which probably absorbed some of the best early commenters into these orgs. Holden’s 2014 writeup on the challenges of transparency seems loosely related if not exactly the same.
Maybe a fortnightly poll on each of those X vs Y topics? Or more cross-posting from GHD substacks like yours, Hannah Ritchie’s, David Nash’s, Lant Pritchett’s etc.
It does seem like some of the “serious” GHD discussion is moving off the forum, e.g. later today I’m attending this online workshop (more info) that touches on your 3rd bullet. This seems part of the wider trend of decision-influencing discussion becoming internalised due to the professionalisation of EA GHD, which probably absorbed some of the best early commenters into these orgs. Holden’s 2014 writeup on the challenges of transparency seems loosely related if not exactly the same.
Maybe a fortnightly poll on each of those X vs Y topics? Or more cross-posting from GHD substacks like yours, Hannah Ritchie’s, David Nash’s, Lant Pritchett’s etc.