From a vlogbrothers video by Hank Green comes the most EA-flavored framing from a non-EA Iโve ever seen. In the following quote from the video heโs referencing the work done by Partners in Health and supported by the YouTube community that exists around him, his brother John Green, and the work they do. More information on that project is in another recent video.
I think about this in the context of this communityโs work in Sierra Leone: already fewer women are dying in childbirth, and that victory is so quiet.
If 3,000 women in West Africa were trapped in a fallen building, there would be international news stories about it; there would be outcry to save them. But if 30,000 women each have a 10% chance of dying in childbirth thatโs the same 3,000 deaths. But due to, I think, just the way the human mind works, we are incapable of seeing that as the same kind of catastrophe, and as fixing it as the same kind of heroism. [emphasis mine]
We need to get way better at accepting the miracle of things that didnโt happen, because thatโs where some of humanityโs greatest victories are hiding. And if we donโt understand that the things that didnโt happen, they might very well begin happening again.
4 votes
Overall karma indicates overall quality.
Total points: 0
Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
Tons of overlap in how the vlogbrothers think about their impact and EA. Great to see.
In particular, there was one episode of their podcast recently (I think it was โThe Green Brothers are Often Wrongโ), where they got comically close to describing themselves as EA; remarking that John was the heart (who cared a lot about people and โwhat was most importantโ) and Hank was the head, being really concerned with science and truth and progress and reasoning.
They are of course aware of EA via large EA participation in their PFA donation drive, but I believe they have a distant, caricatured view of the community itself. I heard of a livestream where they were asked about it and John said something to the effect of โthereโs a lot of harm you can do if you only think of people as objects of analysis for you to intervene on when you should be dealing with them directly and empowering them in the ways that they decide they want to be empowered.โ
4 votes
Overall karma indicates overall quality.
Total points: 1
Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
Aww, that is such a pity. Thanks for sharing that anecdata.
As someone who grew up watching the vlogbrothers I have always felt like we should be allies /โ friends! Fingers crossed, maybe one day ๐ค
1 vote
Overall karma indicates overall quality.
Total points: 0
Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
I put 2 comments on that video that unfortunately havenโt gotten many upvotesโฆ
...
I think YouTube might be shadowbanning me for using UNICODE bold ยฏ\_ (ใ)_/โยฏ