I agree with you, conditional on the person actually going on to donate a kidney, or donating a lot to AMF. Most people don’t however—if they abort the fetus, they won’t make a compensating kidney donation. So it seems like the right comparison for them.
Obviously if utilitarianism etc. are false this argument doesn’t work.
I agree with you, conditional on the person actually going on to donate a kidney, or donating a lot to AMF. Most people don’t however—if they abort the fetus, they won’t make a compensating kidney donation. So it seems like the right comparison for them.
Obviously if utilitarianism etc. are false this argument doesn’t work.