Thanks for explanation. My guess is this decision should not be delegated to LLMs but mostly to authors (possibly with some emphasis on correct classification in the UI).
I think the “the post concerns an ongoing conversation, scandal or discourse that would not be relevant to someone who doesn’t care about the EA community” should not be interpreted extensively, otherwise it can easily mean “any controversy or criticism”. I will repost it without the links to current discussions—these are non-central, similar points are raised repeatedly over the years and it is easy to find dozens of texts making them.
Quick update: I read your post more closely and I actually still feel undecided, so I let my colleague break the tie and they voted not community, so I’ve removed the tag. :)
To clarify: I tried hard to apply the current definition. I expect we will revisit this definition and system in the near future.
Thanks for explanation. My guess is this decision should not be delegated to LLMs but mostly to authors (possibly with some emphasis on correct classification in the UI).
I think the “the post concerns an ongoing conversation, scandal or discourse that would not be relevant to someone who doesn’t care about the EA community” should not be interpreted extensively, otherwise it can easily mean “any controversy or criticism”. I will repost it without the links to current discussions—these are non-central, similar points are raised repeatedly over the years and it is easy to find dozens of texts making them.
Quick update: I read your post more closely and I actually still feel undecided, so I let my colleague break the tie and they voted not community, so I’ve removed the tag. :)
To clarify: I tried hard to apply the current definition. I expect we will revisit this definition and system in the near future.