I currently don’t feel comfortable publishing who applied and did not receive a grant, without first checking in with the applicants. I can imagine that in future round there would be some checkbox that applicants can check to indicate that they feel comfortable with their application being shared publicly even if they do not receive a grant.
I sent you a different email which indicated that I was already planning on sending you feedback directly within the next two weeks. The email which will include that feedback will then also include a request to share it publicly.
There was a small group of people (~7) where I had a sense that direct feedback would be particularly valuable, and you were part of that group, so I sent them a different email indicating that I am going to give them additional feedback in any case, and it was difficult to fit in a sentence that also encouraged them asking for feedback publicly since I had already told them I would send them feedback.
Could you publish also a list of runner-up’s? (i.e. applicants that were closely considered but didn’t make the cut?)
I think that’d be helpful as the community thinks through the decision-making process here.
I currently don’t feel comfortable publishing who applied and did not receive a grant, without first checking in with the applicants. I can imagine that in future round there would be some checkbox that applicants can check to indicate that they feel comfortable with their application being shared publicly even if they do not receive a grant.
Got it.
Do you plan to check with the applicants from this round? Seems quick to do, and could surface a lot of helpful information.
I have told all applicants that I would be interested in giving public feedback on their application, and will do so if they comment on this thread.
Huh, I submitted two applications but didn’t see your note re: public feedback. Perhaps you missed me?
I sent you a different email which indicated that I was already planning on sending you feedback directly within the next two weeks. The email which will include that feedback will then also include a request to share it publicly.
There was a small group of people (~7) where I had a sense that direct feedback would be particularly valuable, and you were part of that group, so I sent them a different email indicating that I am going to give them additional feedback in any case, and it was difficult to fit in a sentence that also encouraged them asking for feedback publicly since I had already told them I would send them feedback.
Got it, thanks.