I couldn’t agree more. Brian, I am absolutely, 100% positive that the only way to greatly improve society’s behaviour (ie. Being veg, donating more, being more of a good person in general) is by altering society’s reward/punishment structure towards favouring positive actions. The desire for social acceptance and fear of social consequences is the main driver of human behaviour.
Regarding Buddhists and empathy, meditators generally believe that the are helping others just by meditating – bringing God’s light down to earth, yadda, yadda, yadda. For example, Paramahansa Yogananda has said that an adept yogi does more to help the world just by meditating than even the most prolific humanitarian. “Meditation is the highest service” is something I read from some guru, forget who. Also, since spiritual people usually consider spiritual practice the most important thing in the world, even more so than “worldly” problems, they think that by promoting their spiritual path, they’re performing the greatest service a person can do. For example, a Buddhist monk may not give money to the poor, but he may perform duties supporting the ashram and thus feel that he’s helping others with their spiritual lives.
Another reason spiritual people often don’t do activism is because their belief in karma makes them fatalistic as they expect individuals’/the world’s fate to play out as dictated by their pre-life karma and thus feel helpless to do anything about it. Believing in karma can be a tricky trap, no doubt. I get past it by telling myself that my altruistic actions are PART OF and not against others’ karmic destiny!!!! Oh yeah, and many meditators think that their actions will create karma (if not done with the proper mindset) that will force them to reincarnate, even if they are “good” actions, and thus try not to “do” much. That’s why I’m such a lazy bum – just avoiding making karma. No just kidding. :^)
I couldn’t agree more. Brian, I am absolutely, 100% positive that the only way to greatly improve society’s behaviour (ie. Being veg, donating more, being more of a good person in general) is by altering society’s reward/punishment structure towards favouring positive actions. The desire for social acceptance and fear of social consequences is the main driver of human behaviour.
Regarding Buddhists and empathy, meditators generally believe that the are helping others just by meditating – bringing God’s light down to earth, yadda, yadda, yadda. For example, Paramahansa Yogananda has said that an adept yogi does more to help the world just by meditating than even the most prolific humanitarian. “Meditation is the highest service” is something I read from some guru, forget who. Also, since spiritual people usually consider spiritual practice the most important thing in the world, even more so than “worldly” problems, they think that by promoting their spiritual path, they’re performing the greatest service a person can do. For example, a Buddhist monk may not give money to the poor, but he may perform duties supporting the ashram and thus feel that he’s helping others with their spiritual lives.
Another reason spiritual people often don’t do activism is because their belief in karma makes them fatalistic as they expect individuals’/the world’s fate to play out as dictated by their pre-life karma and thus feel helpless to do anything about it. Believing in karma can be a tricky trap, no doubt. I get past it by telling myself that my altruistic actions are PART OF and not against others’ karmic destiny!!!! Oh yeah, and many meditators think that their actions will create karma (if not done with the proper mindset) that will force them to reincarnate, even if they are “good” actions, and thus try not to “do” much. That’s why I’m such a lazy bum – just avoiding making karma. No just kidding. :^)