Something seems especially weird about offsetting your purchase of non-BCC chicken by donating to campaigns to get supermarkets to adopt the BCC.
I think one important consideration missing here: supermarkets respond to campaigners by saying that customers want to buy non-BCC chicken, and they are just doing what their customers want. If you buy non-BCC chicken from them, you make that argument stronger, and the campaigners’ argument weaker.
And I don’t think this is necessarily a negligible concern in comparison to the other effects being discussed here, since the mechanism for how your small donation is supposed to help chickens is also by tipping the scales on some corporate campaign and getting a company like a supermarket to make a big change.
Something seems especially weird about offsetting your purchase of non-BCC chicken by donating to campaigns to get supermarkets to adopt the BCC.
I think one important consideration missing here: supermarkets respond to campaigners by saying that customers want to buy non-BCC chicken, and they are just doing what their customers want. If you buy non-BCC chicken from them, you make that argument stronger, and the campaigners’ argument weaker.
And I don’t think this is necessarily a negligible concern in comparison to the other effects being discussed here, since the mechanism for how your small donation is supposed to help chickens is also by tipping the scales on some corporate campaign and getting a company like a supermarket to make a big change.