Thank you for this! I think this sort of challenge and thinking is really valuable and exactly what the EA community needs.
For comparison, the SoGive method of analysing charities advises focusing marginal cost-effectiveness, and not on the ITN framework. I absolutely welcome this thoughtful analysis of the framework.
(Full disclosure: I developed the SoGive method of analysing charities; it’s essentially inspired by EA thinking, but not particularly focused on the ITN framework)
Thank you for this! I think this sort of challenge and thinking is really valuable and exactly what the EA community needs.
For comparison, the SoGive method of analysing charities advises focusing marginal cost-effectiveness, and not on the ITN framework. I absolutely welcome this thoughtful analysis of the framework.
(Full disclosure: I developed the SoGive method of analysing charities; it’s essentially inspired by EA thinking, but not particularly focused on the ITN framework)