I’ve looked into this and here’s (this specific section of the post) a case against this cancelation postulate that builds upon the literature on the topic. :) For something that addresses Owen’s above point in particular, see the second half of the section discussing Tomasik’s argument (which is basically the same afaiu).
(Sharing this here on the off-chance this is also of interest to someone else finding themself lost in this comment thread someday).
I’ve looked into this and here’s (this specific section of the post) a case against this cancelation postulate that builds upon the literature on the topic. :) For something that addresses Owen’s above point in particular, see the second half of the section discussing Tomasik’s argument (which is basically the same afaiu).
(Sharing this here on the off-chance this is also of interest to someone else finding themself lost in this comment thread someday).