In general I agree, but the forum guidelines do state “Polish: We’d rather see an idea presented imperfectly than not see it at all.”, and this is a post explicitly billed as “response” that were invited by Rob. So if this is all the time Mark wants to spend on it, I feel it is perfectly fine to have a post that is only for people who have listened to the podcast/are aware of the debate.
In general I agree, but the forum guidelines do state “Polish: We’d rather see an idea presented imperfectly than not see it at all.”, and this is a post explicitly billed as “response” that were invited by Rob. So if this is all the time Mark wants to spend on it, I feel it is perfectly fine to have a post that is only for people who have listened to the podcast/are aware of the debate.
Oh, what I said wasn’t a criticism, so much as a suggestion to how more people might get up to speed on what’s under debate!