I think we’ll just have to disagree on this point. I think it’s perfectly fine to (politely) call bullshit, if you think something is bullshit, as long as you follow it up with arguments as to why you think that (which she did, even if you think the arguments were weak). I think EA could benefit from more of a willingness to call out emperors with no clothes.
I think it’s perfectly fine to (politely) call bullshit, if you think something is bullshit, as long as you follow it up with arguments as to why you think that
Agreed.
(which she did, even if you think the arguments were weak)
That’s where we disagree—strong claims (“Two Turing-award winners talk nonsense when they point out the dangerousness of the technology they developed”) require strong evidence.
I think we’ll just have to disagree on this point. I think it’s perfectly fine to (politely) call bullshit, if you think something is bullshit, as long as you follow it up with arguments as to why you think that (which she did, even if you think the arguments were weak). I think EA could benefit from more of a willingness to call out emperors with no clothes.
Agreed.
That’s where we disagree—strong claims (“Two Turing-award winners talk nonsense when they point out the dangerousness of the technology they developed”) require strong evidence.