Thanks, Vasco! If you’re completely certain about the relevant questions, then you’re right that this tool won’t inform your personal allocations. Of course, it’s an open question whether that level of confidence is warranted—granting, of course, that this depends partly on your metaethical views, as it’s much more reasonable to be highly confident about your own values than about objective moral norms, if any there are. Still, we hope that a tool like this can be useful for folks like you when they’re coordinating with others. And independently of all that, the tool can serve people with even low levels of uncertainty, as they may uncover various surprising implications of their views.
Thanks, Vasco! If you’re completely certain about the relevant questions, then you’re right that this tool won’t inform your personal allocations. Of course, it’s an open question whether that level of confidence is warranted—granting, of course, that this depends partly on your metaethical views, as it’s much more reasonable to be highly confident about your own values than about objective moral norms, if any there are. Still, we hope that a tool like this can be useful for folks like you when they’re coordinating with others. And independently of all that, the tool can serve people with even low levels of uncertainty, as they may uncover various surprising implications of their views.