I agree with you that as phrased, this question isn’t very useful.
The only way I can think that the EA community would be able to solve this kind of problem would be if an EA organization had detailed notes on everyone earning to give, and used that information to recommend actions to individuals. (This idea is kind of half baked and crazy but I’ve been thinking recently that it might be overall worthwhile.)
I agree with you that as phrased, this question isn’t very useful.
The only way I can think that the EA community would be able to solve this kind of problem would be if an EA organization had detailed notes on everyone earning to give, and used that information to recommend actions to individuals. (This idea is kind of half baked and crazy but I’ve been thinking recently that it might be overall worthwhile.)