Not sure if it fits what you are looking for, but colonialism? A somewhat underappreciated aspect of it was that the belief that spreading Western civilization would make indigenous people better off, see e.g. White man’s burden. Also, the Western powers were obviously very effective at colonizing. On the other hand, it somewhat lacks the part of the “play pump” example where everybody agrees that the responsible people had good intentions. Maybe it could be adapted to tales of Christian proselytizing in Africa, which would be relevant for your audience.
Interesting. Without reading into it, I’ve always assumed that Western defences of colonialism (incl. White Man’s Burden) were somewhat disingenuous, i.e. defending something they knew was wrong, or was at least controversial, and the motivations were not altruistic. The ideal case is one where people are being genuinely altruistic but completely miss the mark.
Not sure if it fits what you are looking for, but colonialism? A somewhat underappreciated aspect of it was that the belief that spreading Western civilization would make indigenous people better off, see e.g. White man’s burden. Also, the Western powers were obviously very effective at colonizing. On the other hand, it somewhat lacks the part of the “play pump” example where everybody agrees that the responsible people had good intentions. Maybe it could be adapted to tales of Christian proselytizing in Africa, which would be relevant for your audience.
Interesting. Without reading into it, I’ve always assumed that Western defences of colonialism (incl. White Man’s Burden) were somewhat disingenuous, i.e. defending something they knew was wrong, or was at least controversial, and the motivations were not altruistic. The ideal case is one where people are being genuinely altruistic but completely miss the mark.