The important nuance here is that while we did not think ACE’s current charity evaluation process measures marginal cost-effectiveness to a sufficient extent to directly rely on ACE’s recommendations, that isn’t the same as the (stronger) claim that its recommendations are necessarily worse donation opportunities than the AWF or THL’s corporate campaigns, and it also isn’t the same as claiming that ACE’s process doesn’t track marginal cost-effectiveness at all.
We can’t say confidently how ACE’s (other) recommendations compare to the AWF or THL’s corporate campaigns, as we haven’t individually evaluated and compared them. So we want to offer donors who have the time and expertise to look into these promising individual charities the opportunity to do so and potentially donate to them if they find them to be maximising impact by their worldview, as we do for many more charities and funds on our platform that we can’t currently justify recommending (for instance because they haven’t been evaluated (yet)).
Thanks for your question!
The important nuance here is that while we did not think ACE’s current charity evaluation process measures marginal cost-effectiveness to a sufficient extent to directly rely on ACE’s recommendations, that isn’t the same as the (stronger) claim that its recommendations are necessarily worse donation opportunities than the AWF or THL’s corporate campaigns, and it also isn’t the same as claiming that ACE’s process doesn’t track marginal cost-effectiveness at all.
We can’t say confidently how ACE’s (other) recommendations compare to the AWF or THL’s corporate campaigns, as we haven’t individually evaluated and compared them. So we want to offer donors who have the time and expertise to look into these promising individual charities the opportunity to do so and potentially donate to them if they find them to be maximising impact by their worldview, as we do for many more charities and funds on our platform that we can’t currently justify recommending (for instance because they haven’t been evaluated (yet)).
You may also be interested in our answer to this somewhat related question under the AMA post.