Hi Sabs. We can discuss this a bit in a comment thread, but the issues here are complicated. If you’d like to have a conversation, I’m happy to chat. Please DM me for a link to my calendar.
Brief replies to your questions:
I think you matter an enormous amount too. I am not saying this facetiously. It’s probably the thing I believe most deeply.
I don’t know how much the median EA thinks you matter.
I’m unsure about all four assumptions. However, I’m also unsure about their practical importance. You might not be comfortable with the results of any cross-species cost-effectiveness analysis.
If it’s you or a hundred chickens, I’d save you. I’d also save my children over a hundred (human) strangers. I don’t think this means that my children realize more welfare than those strangers. Likewise, I don’t think you realize 100x more welfare than a chicken can.
Hi Sabs. We can discuss this a bit in a comment thread, but the issues here are complicated. If you’d like to have a conversation, I’m happy to chat. Please DM me for a link to my calendar.
Brief replies to your questions:
I think you matter an enormous amount too. I am not saying this facetiously. It’s probably the thing I believe most deeply.
I don’t know how much the median EA thinks you matter.
I’m unsure about all four assumptions. However, I’m also unsure about their practical importance. You might not be comfortable with the results of any cross-species cost-effectiveness analysis.
If it’s you or a hundred chickens, I’d save you. I’d also save my children over a hundred (human) strangers. I don’t think this means that my children realize more welfare than those strangers. Likewise, I don’t think you realize 100x more welfare than a chicken can.