Commenters appear to be not unanimous about whether “We all knew that the Cool Earth recommendation was low-confidence.” I don’t have a dispositive answer on this, but my impression (based on anecdotes/conversations with EAs) is that many people consider the Cool Earth conclusion definitive.
I’ll just add that I always read it as a highly tentative recommendation that you’d expect to be overturned if serious resources were put into investigating climate change charity—though I’m unusually in-the-know.
Commenters appear to be not unanimous about whether “We all knew that the Cool Earth recommendation was low-confidence.” I don’t have a dispositive answer on this, but my impression (based on anecdotes/conversations with EAs) is that many people consider the Cool Earth conclusion definitive.
I’ll just add that I always read it as a highly tentative recommendation that you’d expect to be overturned if serious resources were put into investigating climate change charity—though I’m unusually in-the-know.