Thanks! Yes, agreed itās an open empirical question how well people (in general, or particular individuals) can pull off the specified options.
I wouldnāt be terribly surprised if something like (2) turned out to be best for most people most of the time. But I guess Iām sufficiently Aristotelian to think that if weāre raised since childhood to abide by good norms, later learning that theyāre instrumentally justified shouldnāt really undermine them that much. (They certainly havenāt for meāmy wife finds it funny how strongly averse I am to any kind of dishonesty, ādespiteā my utilitarian beliefs!)
Thanks! Yes, agreed itās an open empirical question how well people (in general, or particular individuals) can pull off the specified options.
I wouldnāt be terribly surprised if something like (2) turned out to be best for most people most of the time. But I guess Iām sufficiently Aristotelian to think that if weāre raised since childhood to abide by good norms, later learning that theyāre instrumentally justified shouldnāt really undermine them that much. (They certainly havenāt for meāmy wife finds it funny how strongly averse I am to any kind of dishonesty, ādespiteā my utilitarian beliefs!)