If each job[1] will have a clear place to discuss it, where someone can comment “I think this is harmful because...” and someone else can reply “I think this is wrong because...”, and even the org itself (or 80k) can reply with their take—I would personally say this is a good situation.
Extra bonuses from this solution:
If I want an impactful job, I have a clear place to check if anyone pushed back on this job and why (and also: seeing no pushback is a useful data point)
We get a healthy [in my opinion] conversation about impact within the community
As you said, not “putting too much on 80k”, which I also endorse
How would you plan this exactly? Comments per job posting or per organisation?
On the one hand job postings come and go, so if you think anyone working at [Effective Consultancy] is doing a bad thing, you don’t want to have to keep looking for their postings and re-comment.
On the other hand, maybe you think their [Consultancy Safety] team is currently doing good work, and you want to endorse it temporarily while not endorsing the rest of EC.
(I see that this is old) Etsy’s product reviews for every product in the seller’s shop are all on every product page. There might be some fancy sorting bringing the more relevant reviews to the top, I’m not sure. So with a model like this, you could review one job posting, and people could see that job posting review on all the company’s other job postings.
My vision (agreeing but elaborating):
If each job[1] will have a clear place to discuss it, where someone can comment “I think this is harmful because...” and someone else can reply “I think this is wrong because...”, and even the org itself (or 80k) can reply with their take—I would personally say this is a good situation.
Extra bonuses from this solution:
If I want an impactful job, I have a clear place to check if anyone pushed back on this job and why (and also: seeing no pushback is a useful data point)
We get a healthy [in my opinion] conversation about impact within the community
As you said, not “putting too much on 80k”, which I also endorse
Or each org, I’m not sure
How would you plan this exactly? Comments per job posting or per organisation?
On the one hand job postings come and go, so if you think anyone working at [Effective Consultancy] is doing a bad thing, you don’t want to have to keep looking for their postings and re-comment.
On the other hand, maybe you think their [Consultancy Safety] team is currently doing good work, and you want to endorse it temporarily while not endorsing the rest of EC.
(I see that this is old) Etsy’s product reviews for every product in the seller’s shop are all on every product page. There might be some fancy sorting bringing the more relevant reviews to the top, I’m not sure. So with a model like this, you could review one job posting, and people could see that job posting review on all the company’s other job postings.