It’s rude to the partners with whom 80k is working to say “your org is not impactful, we’re sending people to you with the understanding that they’ll build career capital and leave”.
See 80k’s response, which I interpret as “they are willing to be ‘rude’ and say that an org isn’t top recommended”
We plan to visually distinguish between orgs on our top recommended list (which we think are the most promising places to work in each problem area) and other orgs we list.
JP, regarding your point 3:
See 80k’s response, which I interpret as “they are willing to be ‘rude’ and say that an org isn’t top recommended”
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/YCMgg6x6zWJmran5L/criticism-of-the-80k-job-board-listing-strategy?commentId=zZHtmpFRXGg8SK43b
I endorse their approach here