Same, I have never heard any of these. Perhaps some people are saying these things, but I’d be very surprised to, say, hear anything like this being shared in the EA leaders Slack (not that I’m in it but as someone who has spoken to many EA leaders, they are all chill)
EAs tend to speak in really nuanced ways, so the furthest I’ve heard someone go is saying things like “I’ve found Bayesian reasoning to be an irreplaceable tool and want us to help new EAs learn it and be aware of the value themselves” or “Eating vegan has been shown to increase compassion for animals, and I also think it is important to behave in compassionate ways regardless of impact calculations”. The frugal thing.… I can’t even reword that because I haven’t heard EAs speak that way ever, except from one student organizer who got the idea I think from his own head connecting the dots in the way that made sense to him (he was kind of on his own, not in a hub, and he was organizing before CEA’s UGAP program provided better mentorship to student organizers. I think now that he has graduated and gotten a real job he has gotten over this as he sees how complicated it is to navigate life when being abnormally frugal).
I have this inkling that maybe if people are saying such “rules”, it might be more of a self-soothing technique for some EAs that have struggled to get recognition and the jobs they want in EA? Gatekeeping/no-true-scottsman type stuff? IDK just a vibe, trying to get status where they can maybe. Or maybe they are just dealing with a lot of unexamined distrust toward people different from themselves, as neurodivergents, nerds, and activists tend to do IME?
Same, I have never heard any of these. Perhaps some people are saying these things, but I’d be very surprised to, say, hear anything like this being shared in the EA leaders Slack (not that I’m in it but as someone who has spoken to many EA leaders, they are all chill)
EAs tend to speak in really nuanced ways, so the furthest I’ve heard someone go is saying things like “I’ve found Bayesian reasoning to be an irreplaceable tool and want us to help new EAs learn it and be aware of the value themselves” or “Eating vegan has been shown to increase compassion for animals, and I also think it is important to behave in compassionate ways regardless of impact calculations”. The frugal thing.… I can’t even reword that because I haven’t heard EAs speak that way ever, except from one student organizer who got the idea I think from his own head connecting the dots in the way that made sense to him (he was kind of on his own, not in a hub, and he was organizing before CEA’s UGAP program provided better mentorship to student organizers. I think now that he has graduated and gotten a real job he has gotten over this as he sees how complicated it is to navigate life when being abnormally frugal).
I have this inkling that maybe if people are saying such “rules”, it might be more of a self-soothing technique for some EAs that have struggled to get recognition and the jobs they want in EA? Gatekeeping/no-true-scottsman type stuff? IDK just a vibe, trying to get status where they can maybe. Or maybe they are just dealing with a lot of unexamined distrust toward people different from themselves, as neurodivergents, nerds, and activists tend to do IME?