Also, point 7 about other generations/descendants could be very different under the scenario you outline. You wouldn’t mainly be helping descendants be born outside of NK rather than inside, you’d be helping some be born outside NK instead of not born at all (the descendants of escapees), and others be born in NK instead of not born at all (the other descendants of the families left behind by escapees).
I’m generally delighted that you’re looking into this! I’ve previously mentioned this as an intervention that is potentially on par with GiveWell’s top charities, so if you’ve discovered it independently, it makes me even more optimistic about it.
Also, point 7 about other generations/descendants could be very different under the scenario you outline. You wouldn’t mainly be helping descendants be born outside of NK rather than inside, you’d be helping some be born outside NK instead of not born at all (the descendants of escapees), and others be born in NK instead of not born at all (the other descendants of the families left behind by escapees).
Yes, good point.
I’m generally delighted that you’re looking into this! I’ve previously mentioned this as an intervention that is potentially on par with GiveWell’s top charities, so if you’ve discovered it independently, it makes me even more optimistic about it.