I guess the main criticisms I’ve heard of this kind of proposal are:
a) It might cause EA research to be siloed
b) We might let the standards slip since papers match our worldview and produce low-quality research that harms our reputation
c) It’d be easier for people to just publish here rather than engaging in the hard work of publishing in normal journals which is important for building EA’s credibility
I guess the main criticisms I’ve heard of this kind of proposal are:
a) It might cause EA research to be siloed
b) We might let the standards slip since papers match our worldview and produce low-quality research that harms our reputation
c) It’d be easier for people to just publish here rather than engaging in the hard work of publishing in normal journals which is important for building EA’s credibility