I agree-voted this. This post was much more ‘This argument in favour of X doesn’t work[1]’ rather than ‘X is wrong’, and I wouldn’t want anyone to think otherwise.
Or more precisely, doesn’t work without more background assumptions.
Oh, ok. It’s just that the first sentence and examples gave a slightly different vibe, but it’s more clear now.
I agree-voted this. This post was much more ‘This argument in favour of X doesn’t work[1]’ rather than ‘X is wrong’, and I wouldn’t want anyone to think otherwise.
Or more precisely, doesn’t work without more background assumptions.
Oh, ok. It’s just that the first sentence and examples gave a slightly different vibe, but it’s more clear now.