I think this is a great list and it also aligns with how I want the EA community to be, but also how I perceive the majority of it to already be (with the few exceptions that get outsized attention).
It’s probably just because of the original format, but after renaming #8 from “altruism” to “impartial altruism”, this generates an unfortunate overlap with #11 (impartiality) that might be avoidable (though I’m unsure how).
Regarding #19 (veganism), I feel it’s weird that you just crossed out this point from the original list instead of sharing your own thoughts, so I’d recommend changing it and arguing why you think veganism should or shouldn’t be an EA value.
I think this is a great list and it also aligns with how I want the EA community to be, but also how I perceive the majority of it to already be (with the few exceptions that get outsized attention).
It’s probably just because of the original format, but after renaming #8 from “altruism” to “impartial altruism”, this generates an unfortunate overlap with #11 (impartiality) that might be avoidable (though I’m unsure how).
Regarding #19 (veganism), I feel it’s weird that you just crossed out this point from the original list instead of sharing your own thoughts, so I’d recommend changing it and arguing why you think veganism should or shouldn’t be an EA value.