I think there’s a big difference between “more effective” and “most effective”, and one of the most important and counterintuitive principles of EA is that trying to find the best option rather than just a good option can make a huge difference to how much good you do—we have to prioritise between different goods, and this is painful to do (hence easy to avoid) but really important.
Yeah, I think the tension here is between finding a way to put the motivation that can appeal to all people, and watering it down a bit, or putting it fully in such a manner and accepting that you’re only ever going to be speaking to a small portion of people.
Taking only the “most effective” path towards doing good, when that looks like working on top causes or donating a significant amount, just isn’t open to 90% or more of the population. Is it really wise to focus a movement so narrowly that you rule out most people in the world being able to find a place in it?
Perhaps a compromise is something like the below, where “do more good” is the motto, but with an emphasis on how big that difference can be.
I think there’s a big difference between “more effective” and “most effective”, and one of the most important and counterintuitive principles of EA is that trying to find the best option rather than just a good option can make a huge difference to how much good you do—we have to prioritise between different goods, and this is painful to do (hence easy to avoid) but really important.
Yeah, I think the tension here is between finding a way to put the motivation that can appeal to all people, and watering it down a bit, or putting it fully in such a manner and accepting that you’re only ever going to be speaking to a small portion of people.
Taking only the “most effective” path towards doing good, when that looks like working on top causes or donating a significant amount, just isn’t open to 90% or more of the population. Is it really wise to focus a movement so narrowly that you rule out most people in the world being able to find a place in it?
Perhaps a compromise is something like the below, where “do more good” is the motto, but with an emphasis on how big that difference can be.