How would you ensure people stick to their promise to donate and don’t just use the advice/time for non-earning-to-give causes.
1. We could offer this only to those who already have a public verified record of substantial EA giving.
This would seem to be a reasonable filter/screen on honesty. It is possible that such people would take advantage and not keep the promise to donate the additional amount, but it seems unlikely. Perhaps there are people with a consequentialist ethic who want to help effectively and donate a lot, but are nonetheless willing to be dishonest and swindle fellow-EA-ers, but it doesn’t seem terribly possible.
Note that even if people did not consistently donate the additional negotiated salary, this would still serve as a ‘reward’ for public EA donors, perhaps encouraging others to follow suit.
2. I would suggest that the negotiator/EA sponsor ask them to state their expected salary and salary range and then afterwards to state the amount they were able to negotiate and the amount they had donated. People will probably be less willing to default on their promise if doing so requires explicitly stating this or lying about it.
1. We could offer this only to those who already have a public verified record of substantial EA giving.
This would seem to be a reasonable filter/screen on honesty. It is possible that such people would take advantage and not keep the promise to donate the additional amount, but it seems unlikely. Perhaps there are people with a consequentialist ethic who want to help effectively and donate a lot, but are nonetheless willing to be dishonest and swindle fellow-EA-ers, but it doesn’t seem terribly possible.
Note that even if people did not consistently donate the additional negotiated salary, this would still serve as a ‘reward’ for public EA donors, perhaps encouraging others to follow suit.
2. I would suggest that the negotiator/EA sponsor ask them to state their expected salary and salary range and then afterwards to state the amount they were able to negotiate and the amount they had donated. People will probably be less willing to default on their promise if doing so requires explicitly stating this or lying about it.