Without any context on this situation, I can totally imagine worlds where this is reasonable behaviour, though perhaps poorly communicated, especially if SFF didn’t know they had OpenPhil funding. I personally had a grant from OpenPhil approved for X, but in the meantime had another grantmaker give me a smaller grant for y < X, and OpenPhil agreed to instead fund me for X—y, which I thought was extremely reasonable.
Thanks for sharing.
What the other grantmaker (the one who gave your y) though of this?
Where they aware of your OpenPhil grant when they offered you funding?
Did OpenPhil role back your grant because you did not have use for more than X or some other reason?
I got the OpenPhil grant only after the other grant went through (and wasn’t thinking much about OpenPhil when I applied for the other grant). I never thought to inform the other grant maker after I got the OpenPhil grant, which maybe I should have in hindsight out of courtesy?
This was covering some salary for a fixed period of research, partially retroactive, after an FTX grant fell through. So I guess I didn’t have use for more than X, in some sense (I’m always happy to be paid a higher salary! But I wouldn’t have worked for a longer period of time, so I would have felt a bit weird about the situation)
Thanks for sharing.
What the other grantmaker (the one who gave your y) though of this?
Where they aware of your OpenPhil grant when they offered you funding?
Did OpenPhil role back your grant because you did not have use for more than X or some other reason?
I got the OpenPhil grant only after the other grant went through (and wasn’t thinking much about OpenPhil when I applied for the other grant). I never thought to inform the other grant maker after I got the OpenPhil grant, which maybe I should have in hindsight out of courtesy?
This was covering some salary for a fixed period of research, partially retroactive, after an FTX grant fell through. So I guess I didn’t have use for more than X, in some sense (I’m always happy to be paid a higher salary! But I wouldn’t have worked for a longer period of time, so I would have felt a bit weird about the situation)
Given the order of things, and the fact that you did not have use for more money, this seems indeed reasonable. Thanks for the clarification.