My argument is essentially that “similar income, non impactful job” is as relevant a reference class to the “similar income, impactful job person” as it is as a reference class to the “high income, non impactful job” person. I also personally think reference classes is the wrong way to think about it. If taking a more impactful job also makes someone obliged to take on a lower post donation salary (when they don’t have to), I feel like something has gone wrong, and the incentives are not aligned with doing the most good.
My argument is essentially that “similar income, non impactful job” is as relevant a reference class to the “similar income, impactful job person” as it is as a reference class to the “high income, non impactful job” person. I also personally think reference classes is the wrong way to think about it. If taking a more impactful job also makes someone obliged to take on a lower post donation salary (when they don’t have to), I feel like something has gone wrong, and the incentives are not aligned with doing the most good.