If they already get a price, I wouldn’t call it “honorable mentions” because that unnecessarily diminishes it in my eyes. Just have anything that seems that would get at B- in school be in the same category as the 250$ price?
Ah, I think my worry is that it feels difficult for me to find a standard to rate that actually tracks quality.
Ah, interesting, I have the opposite intuition!:D I completely agree that you shouldn’t give advice about the length of the distillations, but the criteria you mention here just seem really useful and like I’d be surprised if e.g. you find something clearly presented and accessible, and I wouldn’t.
Depth of understanding
Clarity of presentation
Rigor of work
Concision/Length (longer papers will need to present more information than shorter papers)
Originality of insight
Accessibility
And I feel like somebody who has spend like ~40 hours reading and discussing AI Safety material (e.g. as part AGI Safety Fundamentals course) could do a reasonably coherent job at rating the understanding and rigor. Originality seems maybe the trickiest, as you probably have to have some grasp of what ideas/framings are already in the water and which aren’t.
If they already get a price, I wouldn’t call it “honorable mentions” because that unnecessarily diminishes it in my eyes. Just have anything that seems that would get at B- in school be in the same category as the 250$ price?
Ah, interesting, I have the opposite intuition!:D I completely agree that you shouldn’t give advice about the length of the distillations, but the criteria you mention here just seem really useful and like I’d be surprised if e.g. you find something clearly presented and accessible, and I wouldn’t.
And I feel like somebody who has spend like ~40 hours reading and discussing AI Safety material (e.g. as part AGI Safety Fundamentals course) could do a reasonably coherent job at rating the understanding and rigor. Originality seems maybe the trickiest, as you probably have to have some grasp of what ideas/framings are already in the water and which aren’t.