I was surprised to hear anyone claim this was an applause light. My prediction was that many people would hate this idea, and, well, at time of writing the karma score stands at −2. Sure doesn’t seem like I’m getting that much applause :)
I think the optimal number of most bad things is zero, and it’s only not zero when there’s a tradeoff at play. I think most people will agree in the abstract that there’s a tradeoff between stopping bad actors and sometimes punishing the innocent, but they may not concretely be willing to accept some particular costs in the kind of abusive situations we’re faced with at the moment. So, were I to write a post about this, it would be trying to encourage people to more seriously engage with flawed systems of abuse prevention, to judge how their flaws compare to the flaws in doing nothing.
I post about the idea here partly to get a sense of whether this unwillingness to compromise rings true for anyone else as a problem we might have in these discussions. So far, it hasn’t got a lot of traction, but maybe I’ll come back to it if I see more compelling examples in the wild.
I was surprised to hear anyone claim this was an applause light. My prediction was that many people would hate this idea, and, well, at time of writing the karma score stands at −2. Sure doesn’t seem like I’m getting that much applause :)
I think the optimal number of most bad things is zero, and it’s only not zero when there’s a tradeoff at play. I think most people will agree in the abstract that there’s a tradeoff between stopping bad actors and sometimes punishing the innocent, but they may not concretely be willing to accept some particular costs in the kind of abusive situations we’re faced with at the moment. So, were I to write a post about this, it would be trying to encourage people to more seriously engage with flawed systems of abuse prevention, to judge how their flaws compare to the flaws in doing nothing.
I post about the idea here partly to get a sense of whether this unwillingness to compromise rings true for anyone else as a problem we might have in these discussions. So far, it hasn’t got a lot of traction, but maybe I’ll come back to it if I see more compelling examples in the wild.