I am unwilling to take “active members of the EA group” as representative of the EA community, since your actual claim was that I made the experience of the EA community significantly worse, and that includes all members, not simply activists. On average, only 1% of any internet community contribute, but the rest are still community members. Instead, I am fine taking the bet than Benito describes—who is clearly far from friendly to InIn.
I am even fine with going with your lower estimate of 14 out of 20.
I am fine including friends.
I am fine with the two questions, although I would insist the second question be “significantly worse” not simply “negative impact,” since that is the claim we are testing, and the same for “significant preference for Gleb or InIn to not have engaged.” Words matter.
I am fine with having a pledge of $1K to be contributed as either of us has the money to do so in the future. I presume you will eventually have $1K.
I am unwilling to take “active members of the EA group” as representative of the EA community, since your actual claim was that I made the experience of the EA community significantly worse, and that includes all members, not simply activists. On average, only 1% of any internet community contribute, but the rest are still community members. Instead, I am fine taking the bet than Benito describes—who is clearly far from friendly to InIn.
I am even fine with going with your lower estimate of 14 out of 20.
I am fine including friends.
I am fine with the two questions, although I would insist the second question be “significantly worse” not simply “negative impact,” since that is the claim we are testing, and the same for “significant preference for Gleb or InIn to not have engaged.” Words matter.
I am fine with having a pledge of $1K to be contributed as either of us has the money to do so in the future. I presume you will eventually have $1K.
I read “active” to mean actually involved in things, whether socially, online, finding, or campaigning.
The word “activist” has a stronger connotation in spite of the same root.
Fair enough