Calling this âcritical level utilitarianismâ opens you to concerns raised by Ryan (which I share) and doesnât seem to buy you anything.
Just say that $300 is the point at which life is worth living (i.e. thatâs the point at which utility is zero). Then you donât run into weird crap like âsomeone making $200 per year has a life thatâs worth living for them, but makes society a worse place.â
(I would call this point the âneutral levelâ if youâre looking for terminology.)
Calling this âcritical level utilitarianismâ opens you to concerns raised by Ryan (which I share) and doesnât seem to buy you anything.
Just say that $300 is the point at which life is worth living (i.e. thatâs the point at which utility is zero). Then you donât run into weird crap like âsomeone making $200 per year has a life thatâs worth living for them, but makes society a worse place.â
(I would call this point the âneutral levelâ if youâre looking for terminology.)