Strong agree with all of this. ‘Gaming the system’ feels like weaksauce—it’s not like there’s an algorithm evaluators have to agree to in advance, so if CEA feel someone’s responded to the letter but not spirit of their feedback, they can just reject and say that in the rejection.
Strong agree with all of this. ‘Gaming the system’ feels like weaksauce—it’s not like there’s an algorithm evaluators have to agree to in advance, so if CEA feel someone’s responded to the letter but not spirit of their feedback, they can just reject and say that in the rejection.
I strongly disagree, [edit: deleted a sentence]. Happy to talk about this via DM, will send you a DM with my thoughts.
edit: DM sent
Please do, I’d be interested to hear your take :)