As of this comment: 40%, 38%, 37%, 5%. I haven’t taken into account time passing since the button appeared.
With 395 total codebearer-days, a launch has occurred once. This means that, with 200 codebearers this year, the Laplace prior for any launch happening is 40% (1−(1−1396)200). The number of participants is about in between 2019 (125 codebearers) and 2020 (270 codebearers), so doing an average like this is probably fine.
I think there’s a 5% chance that there’s a launch but no MAD, because Peter Wildeford has publicly committed to MAD, says 5%, and he knows himself best.
I think the EA forum is a little bit, but not vastly, more likely to initiate a launch, because the EA Forum hasn’t done Petrov day before and qualitatively people seem to be having a bit more fun and irreverance over here, so I’m giving 3% of the no-MAD probability to EA Forum staying up and 2% to Lesswrong staying up.
Also, the reference class of launches doesn’t fully represent the current situation: last launch was more of a self-destruct. This time, it’s harming another website/community, which seems more prohibitive. So I think the prior is lower than 40%.
As of this comment: 40%, 38%, 37%, 5%. I haven’t taken into account time passing since the button appeared.
With 395 total codebearer-days, a launch has occurred once. This means that, with 200 codebearers this year, the Laplace prior for any launch happening is 40% (1−(1−1396)200). The number of participants is about in between 2019 (125 codebearers) and 2020 (270 codebearers), so doing an average like this is probably fine.
I think there’s a 5% chance that there’s a launch but no MAD, because Peter Wildeford has publicly committed to MAD, says 5%, and he knows himself best.
I think the EA forum is a little bit, but not vastly, more likely to initiate a launch, because the EA Forum hasn’t done Petrov day before and qualitatively people seem to be having a bit more fun and irreverance over here, so I’m giving 3% of the no-MAD probability to EA Forum staying up and 2% to Lesswrong staying up.
Also, the reference class of launches doesn’t fully represent the current situation: last launch was more of a self-destruct. This time, it’s harming another website/community, which seems more prohibitive. So I think the prior is lower than 40%.
There is a chance to remove MAD by removing Peter’s launch codes’ validity, per my request.