The Unjournal (unjournal.org) commissioned the evaluation of one of the biosecurity-relevantpapers you mention (Barberio et al, 2023). See our evaluation package here, with links to each evaluation within.
The evaluators generally agree about the importance and promise of this work, but also express substantial doubts about its credibility and usefulness. (They also make specific suggestions for improvements and extensions, as well as requests for clarification.) The evaluation manager echoes this, noting that the “limitations of the paper as it stands make it far less valuable than it could be.”
The Unjournal (unjournal.org) commissioned the evaluation of one of the biosecurity-relevantpapers you mention (Barberio et al, 2023). See our evaluation package here, with links to each evaluation within.