Yeah, if anything this post should be positioned as an argument against Ryan Carey, not Jonas. Ryan is the one who really ran with the GP label in his comment; it was clearly just a throwaway suggestion in Jonas’s post.
That said, given how much karma Ryan’s comment was getting it’s not obviously unreasonable to prepare a top-level response. But it should be positioned in that context, rather than misrepresenting Jonas’s post.
Yeah, if anything this post should be positioned as an argument against Ryan Carey, not Jonas. Ryan is the one who really ran with the GP label in his comment; it was clearly just a throwaway suggestion in Jonas’s post.
That said, given how much karma Ryan’s comment was getting it’s not obviously unreasonable to prepare a top-level response. But it should be positioned in that context, rather than misrepresenting Jonas’s post.
[Edited to weaken some overstrong phrasing]