There’s not necessarily a contradiction here, as both DGB and Klein describe specific instances (both could be true at the same time).
That said, EAs have, by and large, moved away from recommending forestry offsets for a host of reasons, including difficulty to ensure additionality and permanence.
There’s not necessarily a contradiction here, as both DGB and Klein describe specific instances (both could be true at the same time).
That said, EAs have, by and large, moved away from recommending forestry offsets for a host of reasons, including difficulty to ensure additionality and permanence.
You might also find this relevant: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/RnmZ62kuuC8XzeTBq/why-we-have-over-rated-cool-earth