Hey! Thanks for the thoughts. I’m unfortunately very busy these days (including, with preparing for Manifest 2025!) so can’t guarantee I’ll be able to address everything thoroughly, but a few quick points, written hastily and without strong conviction:
re non sequitor, I’m not sure if you’ve been on a podcast before but one tends to just, like, say stuff that comes to mind; it’s not an all-things-considered take. I agree that Hanania denouncing his past self is a great and probably more central example of growth, I just didn’t reference it because the SWP stuff was more top of mind (interesting, unexpected).
I know approximately nothing about HBD fwiw; like I’m not even super sure what the term refers to (my guess without checking: the controversial idea that certain populations/races have higher IQs?). It’s not the case that I’ve looked a bunch into HBD and decided I’ll invite these 6 speakers because of their HBD beliefs; I outlined the specific reasons I invited them, which is that they each had an interesting topic to talk about (none of which were HBD afaik). You could accuse me of dereliction of duty wrt researching the downstream effects of inviting speakers with controversy? idk, maybe, I’m open to that criticism, it’s just there’s a lot of stuff to juggle and it feels a bit like an isolated demand on my time.
I agree that racism directly harms people, beyond being offensive, and this can be very bad. It’s not obvious to me where and how of racism is happening in my local community (broadly construed, ie the spaces I spend time in IRL and online), or what specific bad things that are caused by this racism? Like, I think my general view of racism is that it’s an important cause area, alongside many other important causes to work on like AI safety, animal welfare, GHD, climate change, progress, etc—but it happens to be not very neglected or tractable, for me personally to address.
Hey! Thanks for the thoughts. I’m unfortunately very busy these days (including, with preparing for Manifest 2025!) so can’t guarantee I’ll be able to address everything thoroughly, but a few quick points, written hastily and without strong conviction:
re non sequitor, I’m not sure if you’ve been on a podcast before but one tends to just, like, say stuff that comes to mind; it’s not an all-things-considered take. I agree that Hanania denouncing his past self is a great and probably more central example of growth, I just didn’t reference it because the SWP stuff was more top of mind (interesting, unexpected).
I know approximately nothing about HBD fwiw; like I’m not even super sure what the term refers to (my guess without checking: the controversial idea that certain populations/races have higher IQs?). It’s not the case that I’ve looked a bunch into HBD and decided I’ll invite these 6 speakers because of their HBD beliefs; I outlined the specific reasons I invited them, which is that they each had an interesting topic to talk about (none of which were HBD afaik). You could accuse me of dereliction of duty wrt researching the downstream effects of inviting speakers with controversy? idk, maybe, I’m open to that criticism, it’s just there’s a lot of stuff to juggle and it feels a bit like an isolated demand on my time.
I agree that racism directly harms people, beyond being offensive, and this can be very bad. It’s not obvious to me where and how of racism is happening in my local community (broadly construed, ie the spaces I spend time in IRL and online), or what specific bad things that are caused by this racism? Like, I think my general view of racism is that it’s an important cause area, alongside many other important causes to work on like AI safety, animal welfare, GHD, climate change, progress, etc—but it happens to be not very neglected or tractable, for me personally to address.