I meant my future decisions would be the same in reality if I could not gather additional evidence
Perhaps, but that’s consistent with incomparability. Given the independent motivations we’ve discussed (/given in my post) for calling the two options incomparable, I’d say you should call them incomparable.
Perhaps, but that’s consistent with incomparability. Given the independent motivations we’ve discussed (/given in my post) for calling the two options incomparable, I’d say you should call them incomparable.
I think I address your questions in the second paragraph in “Why we’re especially unaware of large-scale consequences” (this post) and “Meta-extrapolation” (post #4). See also my discussion with Richard here.