You can get out of the infinite (+/​-) payoffs by exponentially discounting future well-being. This assumes that, while in heaven or hell, you experience a finite amount of well-being at every point in time (that doesn’t grow exponentially without bound), but you live for an infinite amount of time.
I suppose I could see reason to make this assumption, given that you could get used to the luxuries of heaven and it would start to be less pleasurable. However this doesn’t really eliminate the problem because there’s still the possibility that this assumption is incorrect, meaning the probability of infinite payoff is still non-zero and therefore the wager still stands.
You can get out of the infinite (+/​-) payoffs by exponentially discounting future well-being. This assumes that, while in heaven or hell, you experience a finite amount of well-being at every point in time (that doesn’t grow exponentially without bound), but you live for an infinite amount of time.
I suppose I could see reason to make this assumption, given that you could get used to the luxuries of heaven and it would start to be less pleasurable. However this doesn’t really eliminate the problem because there’s still the possibility that this assumption is incorrect, meaning the probability of infinite payoff is still non-zero and therefore the wager still stands.