But the evidence for a reasonable god seems at least as plausible to me.
Although more people throughout history may have believed in an arbitrary unreasonable god… those people seem a lot less knowledgeable and logical then those people who believe a benevolent creator is possible.
The only point I was making was that not all versions of God are equally likely, so the possible utilities of heaven and hell don’t cancel. I don’t know what the most likely form of God is, but it sounds like we both agree that not all of them are equally likely.
But the evidence for a reasonable god seems at least as plausible to me.
Although more people throughout history may have believed in an arbitrary unreasonable god… those people seem a lot less knowledgeable and logical then those people who believe a benevolent creator is possible.
The only point I was making was that not all versions of God are equally likely, so the possible utilities of heaven and hell don’t cancel. I don’t know what the most likely form of God is, but it sounds like we both agree that not all of them are equally likely.