I think the nazi example is too loaded for various reasons (and triggers people’s “well, this is clearly some kind of thought experiment” sensors).
I think there are a number of other examples that I have listed in the comments to this post that I think would show this. E.g. something in the space of “jewish person lies about their religious affiliation in order to escape discrimination that’s unfair to them for something like scholarship money, of which they then donate a portion (partially because they do want to offset the harm that came from being dishonest)”, is I think a better experiment here.
I think people would interpret your post being pretty clearly and strongly against, in a way that doesn’t seem very justified to me (my model of whether this is OK is pretty context-dependent, to be clear).
I think the nazi example is too loaded for various reasons (and triggers people’s “well, this is clearly some kind of thought experiment” sensors).
I think there are a number of other examples that I have listed in the comments to this post that I think would show this. E.g. something in the space of “jewish person lies about their religious affiliation in order to escape discrimination that’s unfair to them for something like scholarship money, of which they then donate a portion (partially because they do want to offset the harm that came from being dishonest)”, is I think a better experiment here.
I think people would interpret your post being pretty clearly and strongly against, in a way that doesn’t seem very justified to me (my model of whether this is OK is pretty context-dependent, to be clear).