I noticed this on my own comment, came back to look at other comments here, and can say I’m already confused. But I already said I was against the idea, and maybe it’s just about getting used to change.
So as more practical feedback: the meaning of the different karma types could be explained better in the hover texts. Currently they’re presented as “agreement” vs. “overall” karma—it’s not clear what the latter means. And the “agreement” hover text basically tries to explain both:
How much do you agree with this, separate from whether you think it’s a good comment?
I would only put “How much do you agree with this?” there, and put “How good is this comment?” (or maybe some clearer but short explanation) in the regular karma hover text.
I noticed this on my own comment, came back to look at other comments here, and can say I’m already confused. But I already said I was against the idea, and maybe it’s just about getting used to change.
So as more practical feedback: the meaning of the different karma types could be explained better in the hover texts. Currently they’re presented as “agreement” vs. “overall” karma—it’s not clear what the latter means. And the “agreement” hover text basically tries to explain both:
I would only put “How much do you agree with this?” there, and put “How good is this comment?” (or maybe some clearer but short explanation) in the regular karma hover text.