Well, all disagreements in philosophy ultimately come down to intuitions, not just those in population ethics! The question I was pressing is what, if anything, the authors think we should infer from data about intuitions. One might think you should update toward people’s intuitions, but that’s not obvious to me, not least when (1) in aggregate, people’s answers are inconsistent and (2) this isn’t something they’ve thought about.
Well, all disagreements in philosophy ultimately come down to intuitions, not just those in population ethics! The question I was pressing is what, if anything, the authors think we should infer from data about intuitions. One might think you should update toward people’s intuitions, but that’s not obvious to me, not least when (1) in aggregate, people’s answers are inconsistent and (2) this isn’t something they’ve thought about.