I think one could argue that creating an index across causes makes sense, because it allows for exposure on things that are hard to compare (eg, we are not perfect utilitarians). I think in practical terms, it would help EAs have some reference and an easy way to donate across causes. For example, one could create a fund that is indexed to the elicited preferences of the EA community, or to some group of experts. The closest I am aware of is what Giving What We Can do.
I think one could argue that creating an index across causes makes sense, because it allows for exposure on things that are hard to compare (eg, we are not perfect utilitarians). I think in practical terms, it would help EAs have some reference and an easy way to donate across causes. For example, one could create a fund that is indexed to the elicited preferences of the EA community, or to some group of experts. The closest I am aware of is what Giving What We Can do.
I think that would be more analogous to a mutual fund: you pick and choose the charities that look particularly good. Thatโs what EA Funds do.